Screenshot: Obsidian / Kotaku
2022 introduced us plenty of wealthy narratives in video games. Whereas heavy hitters like God of Battle: Ragnarok, Elden Ring, or Future 2’s The Witch Queen growth are more likely to have their praises sung the loudest, there have been additionally video games like Obsidians’ Pentiment which can be equally deserving of our consideration.
Pentiment is a piece of interactive historic fiction and although the sport may be essentially the most rewarding for historical past wonks, its historic grounding and well-written NPCs (who by no means really feel like they exist simply to spout historical past classes) make it certainly one of this 12 months’s greatest storytelling accomplishments. We sat down with Josh Sawyer, Fallout: New Vegas, Pillars of Eternity, and Pentiment’s director, to speak about how the crew wove historical past and narrative so seamlessly into its characters.
Pentiment is a homicide thriller set within the late 16th century. The historic premise and detective plot is interesting by itself, nevertheless it’s the pure interactions with numerous NPCs that maintain me glued to this recreation. Everybody feels distinctly actual, with objective and information, and serve to sketch the historic background of the fictional city of Tassing particularly, but in addition late medieval Europe. It’s each a historical past lesson and a personality research, and engrossing the entire method by way of.
Learn Extra: This Killer Narrative Sport From Obsidian Is A Should-Play
Talking with Kotaku, director Josh Sawyer describes the method of selecting who to ship what historic classes as an necessary aspect of world and character constructing. It wasn’t sufficient for Pentiment to easily be sure every character would have a justifiable cause for his or her information. A personality’s private pursuits and who they’re on the planet can be taken under consideration, and that shapes, when, the place, and the way they inform their tales
“It’s truly been a problem for lots of my profession, and so one thing over the previous couple of video games that I’ve labored on is when characters are going to primarily have interaction in exposition, my query often to the author is ‘why is that this character the character to inform the story?’ As a result of if the reply is ‘properly, we’d like somebody to inform it,’ that’s not an excellent reply.”
Sawyer continues: “The [exposition] that’s being instructed has to imply one thing that’s actually necessary to the particular person telling it. And I feel that’s most likely why individuals really feel prefer it feels extra pure than, for instance in the event you’re in a historical past class, or a social research class, and somebody’s sort of lecturing at you.”
An instance Sawyer provides is Til Kreutzer, certainly one of Pentiment’s characters who readily talks of the world’s historical past—notably that of the Romans who predate this era.. However that information should come from someplace necessary to the character. By means of the sport we study that he had been given entry to the church’s library, entry that he not has. Mixed with the place he works, Til turns into a pure supply of worldbuilding for Tassing (establishing his historical past with the church) in addition to the historical past of the area.
Screenshot: Obsidian / Kotaku
“[Til] works within the area. And he seems on the Roman ruins on a regular basis. He’s a shepherd. And he’s like ‘I really like books and I really like the tales in regards to the Romans’ and I feel it comes throughout that that is one thing that he actually cares about and is taken with. When Andreas sees the determine bounce throughout the aqueduct, [that’s why Kreutzer says] ‘oh yeah, who is aware of what number of Roman [spirits] are right here.’”
The scene Sawyer refers to is one the place the protagonist, Andreas, spies what’s assumed to be a ghost close to the Roman ruins (although it’s not totally clear what it’s). Til is a pure match to supply the context and add to the spookiness of the scene, because of his realized information and proximity to the ruins themselves. This scene, and former conversations with Til, paint a portrait of a dwelling historical past inside Tassing. That historical past is each seen and unseen, within the ruins and tales individuals inform. It’s what makes the sighting of the apparition all of the extra spooky, though there doesn’t seem like something supernatural happening within the recreation by any means.
Had Til simply been a bathroom normal NPC who delivered traces of dialogue about ruins, and never one thing with a private curiosity and a little bit of a backstory as to how he developed that curiosity, this scene wouldn’t land with the identical weight.
A recurring theme in Pentiment is the historical past of paganism within the area. Whereas the city is totally Christianized and plenty of characters embrace that religion, outdated beliefs and customs usually are not simply forgotten. As you’re unfolding increasingly more of Pentiment’s story, you get a higher sense of the trail that lies between completely different historic eras, and the way that feeds into the day by day lives of those individuals. For this, Sawyer described Sick Peter as an efficient conduit for an understanding of how issues have been earlier than the church.
“Sick Peter is likely one of the repositories of pagan information inside the neighborhood and he resents that the brand new abbot doesn’t actually respect their traditions. So that is one thing that’s necessary to him. He believes it’s necessary to proceed working towards [older traditions] and he sort of resents the abbot and is a little bit bitter that younger individuals don’t keep in mind these outdated methods.”
Pentiment’s characters aren’t merely delivering “summary” historical past classes, Sawyer says, and that’s what makes them work so properly as the first story movers. The person pursuits of every character impression your work as you examine potential motives and unpack the sticky intersectional material which may have led to the homicide in query. Every part is inherently tied up in historic and political connections. Chatting with nearly any character is a chance for the sport to indicate off the historic analysis that went into its improvement, whereas additionally offering numerous hints about different characters, giving Andreas what he must piece the homicide thriller collectively.
However none of that may resonate, whether or not it’s fictional or not, if these characters didn’t have private investments in what they’re speaking about or didn’t really feel like actual individuals. Sawyer’s in depth work to ascertain them as plausible figures is what makes Pentiment’s characters so fascinating.
Screenshot: Obsidian / Kotaku
Greater than the rest in Pentiment, I loved my time with these characters, studying about their lives, and sharing meals with them. What they must say in regards to the world, each the broader one which exists exterior of the bounds of Tassing and their day by day lives as properly, is what pulled me into the homicide thriller. Nobody felt like a generic NPC townsperson tasked with strolling round in circles delivering historical past classes.
“These are all tales which can be necessary to those particular person individuals” Sawyer mentioned, “and I attempt to guarantee that the writers talk the connection of the story to the particular person, not simply the story itself. As a result of in the event you don’t talk each, it’s gonna not really feel good.”
Pentiment is a singular recreation. One which is probably not for everybody. However in 2022, it stands as a stellar instance of how intentional selections over who tells what story satisfies the utility of educating the participant in regards to the world whereas additionally presenting characters who’ve an funding on the planet round them. That impact is contagious, resulting in you the participant in flip caring in regards to the world of the sport and the time you spend in it.