The Lord of the Rings: Return to Moria review: fathoms to go

The Lord of the Rings: Return to Moria treads a really acquainted gameplay loop in a world that isn’t fairly match for objective. The premise is one that ought to fill any Lord of the Rings fan with emotions of pleasure and marvel: with the ability to discover Moria to your coronary heart’s content material is sort of extraordinary in video video games, with the exception being the Mines of Moria growth for The Lord of the Rings On-line. However Return to Moria is an open-world survival recreation shoehorned right into a linear atmosphere. Its mechanics always battle in opposition to each other and frustrate greater than they entertain.

Going down after the occasions of the primary trilogy throughout the Fourth Age of Center-earth, Lord Gimli — voiced as soon as once more by John Rhys-Davies — has summoned all of the dwarves to Moria in an try and reclaim it from goblins, orcs, cave trolls, and loads of different foes who’ve arrange store within the as soon as magnificent kingdom of Khazad-dûm. Return to Moria begins with you stranded over 200 fathoms deep after the ground provides method beneath you, separating you from the mining firm.

Your one core goal, above all else, is to seek out your method again to your fellow dwarves. To take action, you could discover, and finally conquer, the whole thing of the well-known underground labyrinth, which is laden with all method of enemies. Loads of the same old survival recreation tropes are right here, from beginning with weak instruments and weapons and regularly upgrading them as you discover rarer supplies and construct extra succesful machines, to starvation and weariness meters that restrict the quantity you’re able to doing in a set interval.

Picture: Free Vary Video games/North Seaside Video games through Polygon

This is the reason it’s all of the extra baffling that the world you’re in a position to discover is so restrictive. Take Valheim, for instance, essentially the most related comparability within the style. Sure biomes within the Viking-themed survival recreation are harder, with monsters past your stage and rarer supplies to which you could regularly progress; however you continue to have the liberty to discover wherever you want and make errors. By accident stumbling upon a area far past your capabilities, then fleeing together with your tail between your legs, is a part of the enjoyable. It provides intrigue and a want to change into robust sufficient and uncover the secrets and techniques that high-level space holds.

Return to Moria is devoid of those moments as a result of, regardless of the world being procedurally generated, you’re underground. And reasonably than permitting the participant to choose a route and begin digging, the map consists of tiles, with corridors to excavate at very particular areas. You possibly can discover off the overwhelmed observe a little bit and discover areas to return to later down the road, however there’s little to correctly pique your curiosity. There are references to the movie trilogy all through that you could be encounter — Gandalf has left a plethora of notes warning about what’s coming within the subsequent space, and you will discover the room the place Frodo was saved by his mithril shirt, for instance. However by and huge, it is a survival recreation that has Lord of the Rings-themed set dressing reasonably than something significant to say concerning the lore or world it inhabits — moments of ha, that’s neat, earlier than you shortly transfer on, as a substitute of something that sticks with you.

This tile-based system is much more irritating, because it provides suffocating linearity to a style that thrives on open-endedness. In different survival video games, exploration is most rewarding when carried out regularly across the place you select to arrange store, which suggests you’re by no means straying too removed from the security and luxury of your mattress. You possibly can retailer all of your hard-earned minerals, health-replenishing meals, and different sources in a chest, increasing in a form of concentric circle round your base over time.

Picture: Free Vary Video games/North Seaside Video games through Polygon

Return to Moria provides you all of the instruments for any such exploration loop, however pushes you in basically a straight line as you seek for a method out to return to the corporate. This linearity is boring, sure, but it surely additionally intrudes on the complete resource-gathering loop. By the point I had reached the titular Mines of Moria, the journey again to my house base to get well the dear sources I’d left behind had change into a prolonged trek, taking on a lot of the in-game day. It was extended due to the portions of patrolling goblins, wolves, and bears loitering within the halls, which might doubtless be way more manageable enjoying with pals, however solo they made it extra of a problem than was crucial.

Quick journey could be a easy answer to those frustrations, however unlocking it requires black diamonds, a useful resource that may solely be discovered throughout horde assaults — which, when enjoying solo and never with pals, are immensely robust to outlive — or from orc chests, which appear to have a reasonably low drop charge. Slaying bosses may reward you with black diamonds, however these are few and much between. You could then spend these at your bases to both craft a mapstone from scratch, or rebuild a ruined one. However you could do that at every particular person base as a way to designate them as fast-travel areas, and if you happen to’ve hauled your self all the way in which again to your preliminary hovel, you’d don’t have any motive to return there when you’ve collected your left-behind belongings. Thus, fast-travel isn’t an choice till after it could be most helpful.

Picture: Free Vary Video games/North Seaside Video games through Polygon

All of this back-and-forth touring is made extra painful by the lackluster, two-dimensional fight. There are just a few completely different weapon varieties at your disposal when you’ve made it to Orc City (the area containing the primary boss within the recreation, after about 8-10 hours), equivalent to a sword, maul, or battle ax, however they provide little except for strengths in opposition to the various enemy varieties. Gentle assault, heavy assault, or block — these are the three choices out there to you, and the janky enemy AI, which sees them get caught on terrain or run behind you, makes it all of the extra infuriating.

Return to Moria isn’t the worst offender in a sea of dangerous survival video games, and there’s definitely enjoyment to be discovered exploring Khazad-dûm’s depths if you happen to’re with pals — however as a primarily solo dwarf, progress is sluggish, fight is irritating, and exploration options far an excessive amount of backtracking within the linear world you’re in. There’s a sure satisfaction in upgrading my gear and taking out harder enemies, and finally, I nonetheless need to get again to Lord Gimli. However the construction of the sport is at odds with the mechanics, and the disappointing fight doesn’t assist. Just a few patches might see this change into a survival recreation that may maintain its personal in opposition to the extra widespread entries within the style, however because it stands, maybe the dwarves ought to’ve let the orcs declare Moria and constructed their new kingdom some place else.

The Lord of the Rings: Return to Moria was launched Oct. 24 on PlayStation 5, Home windows PC, and Xbox Sequence X. The sport was reviewed on PC utilizing a pre-release obtain code offered by North Seaside Video games. Vox Media has affiliate partnerships. These don’t affect editorial content material, although Vox Media could earn commissions for merchandise bought through affiliate hyperlinks. Yow will discover extra details about Polygon’s ethics coverage right here.

Join the

e-newsletter

Patch Notes

A weekly roundup of the very best issues from Polygon